Muttontown, NY Real Estate

Muttontown NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Muttontown NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Muttontown: $2,436,432 / County Average: $1,116,585

Average Taxes in Muttontown: $41,179 / County Average: $18,689

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Muttontown: $429 / County Average: $375

Average Walkscore in Muttontown: 19 / County Average: 51

Average Year Built in Muttontown: 1979 / County Average: 1958

Average Days on Website in Muttontown: 152 / County Average: 92

Muttontown NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhood in Muttontown NY

Oyster Bay

Areas in Muttontown NY

Brookfield Estates Muttontown Knolls Pen Mor Farms
Stone Hill

Most Popular Listing

Popular Muttontown Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Muttontown Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Muttontown Real Estate

Listings in Muttontown

Fabulous 6000 sq ft home. beautiful stone hill of Muttontown. opportunity to build your custom dream home in this exclusive ...

beautiful traditional brick colonial on over 2 fabulous acres in the heart of pen mor farms in Muttontown. captivati...

New to market!! custom mid-century sprawling ranch with open floor plan, oversize rooms, large windows, slate roof on pretty and level two acre property with room for pool...

R new home in the stately community of stone hill Muttontown at an unbelievable price. a fabulous floor plan is available ...

Y leading into this spacious split home, close to Muttontown preserve, featuring four bedrooms and three full baths, lvrm/fpl, formal dining broom, den, close to syosset schools! low taxes! ho...

5 bath custom home situated on 2 park like acres in the heart of Muttontown. entry foyer leads to formal living room and sunken ...

This is a 2 acre land parcel. additional adjacent lot also offered for sale which is also 2 acres...

construction to begin june 1, completion xmas 2019, time to customize! a stone hill at Muttontown custom co...

Designed by renowned architect maurice fatio. enter through a private 8ft brick wall called the walls of jericho, a circular driveway reveals this amazing colonial manor house with capacious rooms, 6700 sq ft of character, the library with secret bookshelf, 7 bedroom, 7 full baths, redone eat in kitchen, original butlers pantry, 4 marble fireplace's, private guest suite, all french doors with views of terrace and english gardens, great for entertaining, rare opportunity to own a part of history...

The celebrity provenance of this majestic high-tech & high-security mediterranean style estate sets the stage for an ultra elegant lifestyle...

Mint condition! 4 bedroom 3 bath ranch sits on 2 acres...

Stunning 7-bedroom colonial in stone hill. beautifully sited on 1...

Almost completely original, but maintained french norman from 1929...

Muttontown. custom colonial built in 2007 with the finest materials for the owners...

Th the allure of the "gold coast". near by is the Muttontown preserve of over 450 acres . **taxes are being grieved**...

Majestic 8,000 sqft brick colonial with bridal staircase, double story entry foyer, grand living rm, 7 bedrooms, 6...

Updated sprawling ranch, great room, large kitchen, fdr, master bdrm w/ tray ceiling, hardwood floors, gas heating, great 2 acre property w/ pool - syosset schools...

One of a kind/better than new/electric gate entry, 2 mag...

Calling all builder/developers,wonderful opportunity to build in luxury gated community of stone hill Muttontown.only 15 remaining lots ran...

Spacious 5/6 bedroom colonial, hardwood floors, eik, granite countertops, updated windows, large den/fpl...

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

La Rosa Realty, New York
1979 Marcus Avenue Suite 210
Lake Success, NY