Shelter Island, NY Real Estate

Shelter Island NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Shelter Island NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Shelter Island: $1,892,591 / County Average: $856,059

Average Taxes in Shelter Island: $8,520 / County Average: $12,596

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Shelter Island: $616 / County Average: $295

Average Walkscore in Shelter Island: 11 / County Average: 26

Average Year Built in Shelter Island: 1969 / County Average: 1973

Average Days on Website in Shelter Island: 175 / County Average: 100

Shelter Island NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhood in Shelter Island NY

Shelter Island

Areas in Shelter Island NY

Silver Beach

Most Popular Listing

Popular Shelter Island Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Shelter Island Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Shelter Island Real Estate

Listings in Shelter Island

D by nature, from this quaint 2br, 1ba cottage on Shelter Island's lake, known as "fresh pond". entertain on your waterside elevated deck ...

This well thought out property is designed for a 3,868 square feet home with 2 master suites and 3 additional bedrooms with bathrooms, the kitchen is suited for any cook...

This 2.2 acre property allows for so many possibilities...

Stunning, with ornately landscaped expansive grounds,it creates a classic english countryside atmosphere...

The perfect hamptons alternative- 110 ft dock and private beach situated on coecles harbor...

large backyard, 10 x 20 deck off kitchen with grill, covered wrap around front porch with views of greenport harbor & Shelter Island ferry. bay beach at the end of the street. may $5,000; june $6,500; aug-ld $13,500; sept $5,000...

Dramatic waterfront estate with sweeping circular driveway, 12,142 sq ft cedar shake manor house with entry foyer, 4 hearths, commercial kitchen, dr/ballroom, lr/bar, windowed porch/sunroom, 4 blue stone patios with total 3523 sq ft, sweeping lawn to tennis, private beach, dock & 8 moorings...

Move in ready -5 bedroom cape cod completely renovated from top to bottom... incredible opportunity to experience Shelter Island's peace & beauty...

Build your dream home on your dream island...


Rovides the serenity and features so typical of a Shelter Island property. close proximity to crescent beach, this 3 bedroom 2 bath home has all the features to make your vacation memorable...

great storage , prime location, new sprinkler system, new arborvitaes, hardwood floors, driveway repaved with belgian block border, 5 min to town,2 min to long beach , 5 min to Shelter Island ferry-turnkey...

Beautiful waterfront home on west neck creek on Shelter Island...

Centrally located, house recently renovated, new kitchen with granite countertop, all updated appliances, baths, refinished oak floors, recently painted...

stunning six bedroom bayfront home with panoramic views of peconic bay, Shelter Island and beyond! the most desired beach a...


century raised ranch on quiet street on tranquil Shelter Island. many new upgrad...

Secluded waterfront property on menantic creek. boasts 2 waterfront master en-suites...

Spectacular waterfront estate property, 4.3 acres w add'l 2...

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

La Rosa Realty, New York
1979 Marcus Avenue Suite 210
Lake Success, NY